Butterfield Lake Cottage Owners Association

Welcome to Butterfield Lake – a place to relax, connect, and enjoy the beauty of the water. Whether you’re a cottage owner or a guest, we invite you to celebrate our lake, protect its natural legacy, and make lasting memories along the shore. 

CSLAP reports

Understaning our lake.

BLCOA: Become a Member

Working to protect our lake for generations to come.

Boating Information

Boat responsibly.

Annual Events

Join us for community events around the lake

Public Boat Launch

New York State Department of Environmental Conservation

Grass Island

Shepherd's Rock

Elmhurst Island

Garrett's Tavern Island

Spencer Bay

Carpenter's Point

Mink Point

Crow Point

Round Island

Green Island

Van Island

Bickelhaup's Point

Spring Point

Butternut Point

Windmill

Black Creek

Elephant Rock

Bushies Island

Upper Big Island

Lower Big Island

Bulldog Point

Bulldog Bay

Snake Island

Butterfield Bay

Mappies Rocks

Checkerd Rocks

Fisherman's Rest

Pat Island

Muskalonge Bay

Sweet Point

Contact Us

Butterfield Lake, located in Redwood, New York, is a tranquil 962-acre lake ideal for fishing, boating, and wildlife observation. For more details on the lake or annual events, reach out to the BLCOA with the contact form below.

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Name